Seth Slabaugh, writing for the Indianapolis Star, reports that the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission (IURC) will be holding hearings on utility tree trimming practices.
I’m biased on this issue after having had my own run-in with an electric company that wanted to cut down some of my trees. I had a line of trees blocking my house from a busy road to the west and, beyond that, a big expanse of field where the wind could really get howling. The line of trees were a barrier to the wind and the road. They were under some electric transmission lines, but the tops of the trees were something like 15 feet below the power lines. One day, my wife found people working on behalf of the electric company starting to take a chain saw to one of the trees and, naturally, asked them what the hell they were doing. They said they were with the electric company and apparently mumbled something about how we should have received notice. In fact there had been notice and my wife made them get off our property. I went and dug up the easement for the power lines, read it, and exchanged letters with counsel for the power company where I explained why their easement gave them no right to cut down my trees. The company never formally agreed with me, but they just sort of disappeared and our trees remained untouched until we eventually moved. I forget the exact language, but the easement gave them the right — understandably — to take reasonable measures to keep vegetation from interfering with their power lines.
And that’s the problem, as I see it. Power companies usually just want to take a chainsaw to the trees which is probably the cheapest solution but isn’t necessarily permitted by the terms of their easement if there are less intrusive (even if more expensive) ways for them to keep trees from interfering with their power lines.
In Muncie, the IURC hearing is scheduled for 8/31 at 6 p.m. at the Central High School auditorium. On the pro-property owner side of the issue is Charlie Goodman who has a website. He reports that the IURC will also hold these additional hearings:
Indianapolis – Pike High School – September 2
Seymour – September 8
Merrillville – September 23
Fort Wayne – September 29
Evansville – October 7
The Office of the Utility Consumer Counselor has more information here.